Should I give him another year?

Discussion in 'Trail Cams and Photography' started by jeff stewart, Dec 27, 2010.

  1. btech29

    btech29 Platnium Member<br>Forum Sponsor<br>Stud Duck

    Looks like a good young deer, but not too young. Thats your call. :up:
     

  2. jeff stewart

    jeff stewart Active Member

    Thanks! Hey I guess you can see I finally figured it out!:clap: Ive got a few more pics of him I will post:up:
     
  3. btech29

    btech29 Platnium Member<br>Forum Sponsor<br>Stud Duck

    Your in like flem now. :up:
     
  4. green_head_getter

    green_head_getter Super Member<br>2010 Bowhunting Contest Winner

    I Probably wouldn't although I would say he needs one. I would be very tempted tho
     
  5. Tink

    Tink Platinum Member<br>2011-2012 Bowhunting Contest Te

    Good looking deer like Btech said your choice.
     
  6. thats your choice like already said. If it were me I would try and take him. But thats your call.
     
  7. jeff stewart

    jeff stewart Active Member

    Yeah ... I wish I could tell yall Ive had the chance to make a choice but he hasnt given me a chance yet. If he does Im affraid we will probably be havin some gravy and biscuits with some tenderloin that night!:fit:
     
  8. Whiskey River

    Whiskey River Member<br>2007 Bowhunting Contest Team Winner<br>2

    He made it this long... yeah, give him til next October. :up:
     
  9. seymore whitetail

    seymore whitetail Well-Known Member

    It would be very hard for me to pass him up. Im with you JS!! Biscuit's and gravy!!:up:
     
  10. SR4

    SR4 Super Member<br>'07/'08 Bowhunting Contest Team Wi

    I wouldn't give him an extra step and sure wouldnt give him an extra year. But thats just me. My standards aren't that high.
     
  11. jsilver919

    jsilver919 Well-Known Member

    public land drop em in a heart beat! private land it would be a hard choice and i'd prolly end up lettin him walk.

    your choice but if he is near someone elses land (assuming your on private land) and there was a chance he would get taken by a neighbor i'd shoot him
     
  12. austincrutchfield

    austincrutchfield Well-Known Member

    I would run a slick trick through him first chance i got, but its your decision and not anyone elses. Good luck with your decision:up:
     
  13. Hobbshunter

    Hobbshunter Well-Known Member

    11,584
    495
    NWA
    As everyone has said, it's a personal decision.

    Here's what my decision would be... You cant kill them with trail cams. I'd hunt him. If I got the chance this year, which is no small feat, I'd shoot him. If not, he grows another year. Now that's a win-win!
     
  14. Hog_54

    Hog_54 Well-Known Member

    The only way he walks if I miss him with 100gr Spitfire, nice looking buck
     
  15. brbowhunter

    brbowhunter Well-Known Member

    Looks like to me he has a wound on his front left leg....
     
  16. x's 2....I was wondering if he even has a "leg", looks amputated there at the knee to me.
     
  17. AfterLife

    AfterLife Sponsor<br>www.AboveAndBelowOutdoors.com

    i am 50/50 on him. looks like 2.5-3
    nice buck if you have not taken one, but then again, this late in season, might as well wait and see
     
  18. Gary R

    Gary R Well-Known Member

    Another year for what?