I can't speak about the substitutes, but real black powder will last for decades if it's stored properly.
I know guys that keep it in the freezer.
Spot
I know guys that keep it in the freezer.
Spot
Sam, do you think it was the powder itself breaking down, or did the pellets become brittle or crumbly? I've heard of the pellets coming apart and doing awful things to the accuracy.I had fits with my muzzleloader last year try'n to get it to shoot, turned out the pyrodex pellets I was shooting were bad. They were about 3 or 4 years old and it was shooting all over the place. I thought it was the gun, but when I got some new pellets, it shot perfect. After get'n the new ones and shooting them and then loading up with the old ones, you could feel and hear the difference.
I've heard of old timers literally drying out old nasty damp powder and then going to war with it. Black powder: It's nasty, foul-smelling, and is a chore to clean up, but that stuff has been around for centuries and it still works. When the subsitutes have been in use for four or five hundred years, we'll know somthing about those powders, too. :biggrin:I'm still using black powder that I bought in the mid 70's. As long as it stays dry it'll work as if it were bought yesterday.
Cache
Mine was manufactured I think in 2002, and I bought it in Jan-Feb of 2004 from Walmart. That answer your question?You are making be wonder how old the Triple 7 and Pyrodex is on the shelves at Wal-Mart. They mark it down after the season then I wonder if they box it up and save for the next year.